Model wearing Tiffany & Co. sterling silver cuff bracelets against a Tiffany blue background

Sell Your Tiffany & Co.

America’s most storied jeweler — from Schlumberger masterworks to iconic collections, your Tiffany pieces deserve expert representation.

The House That Defined American Luxury

When Charles Lewis Tiffany opened his first store on Broadway in 1837, he set out to create an American jewelry house that could rival the great European maisons. Nearly two centuries later, Tiffany & Co. has not only achieved that goal but has become perhaps the most recognized jewelry brand in the world — the robin’s-egg blue box an icon that transcends the industry.

What makes Tiffany exceptional at auction is the house’s dual legacy: accessible luxury (the Return to Tiffany collection, Elsa Peretti designs, Paloma Picasso pieces) alongside extraordinary high jewelry and the work of legendary designers. Jean Schlumberger’s fantastical creations — the Bird on a Rock brooch, the enamel and diamond bracelets — represent some of the most collectible signed jewelry of the 20th century.

The Tiffany auction market extends beyond jewelry into silver, decorative arts, and even stained glass (Tiffany Studios, the work of Louis Comfort Tiffany). This breadth means a single estate with Tiffany pieces may contain items appealing to entirely different collector categories — each requiring specific expertise to catalog and market correctly.

Why Sell Your Tiffany & Co. at Auction?

Auction delivers what private-sale channels can’t: global reach, competitive bidding, and fully transparent pricing — all on your timeline.

Global Collector Reach

Our Tiffany piece auctions attract serious collectors from across the US, Europe, and Asia — bidders who understand and reward quality.

Net More, Risk Less

No listing fees, no photography, cataloging, marketing, or unsold-lot fees. We handle insured storage, presentation, and the sale itself until your piece finds its buyer.

Specialist Care

Every Tiffany piece consignment is reviewed by a dedicated specialist — authenticated, researched, cataloged, and positioned for maximum appeal.

What Makes Your Tiffany Valuable at Auction

Designer Attribution

Pieces by Jean Schlumberger, Elsa Peretti, Paloma Picasso, and Angela Cummings carry significant premiums over unsigned Tiffany production jewelry. Schlumberger pieces in particular — especially the Bird on a Rock series, enamel bracelets, and nature-inspired brooches — are among the most sought-after signed jewelry at auction.

Period & Rarity

Victorian-era Tiffany pieces (when the house competed at world expositions), Art Nouveau work from the early 1900s, and mid-century designer pieces occupy different collector markets with distinct pricing dynamics. Limited production designs and special commissions command the highest premiums.

Gemstone Quality

Tiffany has historically sourced exceptional gemstones — the house popularized the tanzanite and has access to extraordinary colored stones. Tiffany-set diamonds with Tiffany certification carry their own premium in the secondary market.

Notable Tiffany Results

A selection of results from recent FORTUNA sales. For the full archive picture, see our Tiffany & Co. results guide.

Tiffany & Co. Art Deco diamond and emerald bracelet

Art Deco Bracelet

Diamond & Emerald

$68,750

Tiffany & Co. antique moonstone and sapphire necklace

Antique Moonstone Necklace

Moonstone & Sapphire

$30,000

Tiffany & Co. Cummings bangle

Cummings Bangle

Signed Design

$18,750

Tiffany & Co. antique Egyptian Revival scarab necklace

Egyptian Revival Necklace

Antique Scarab Motif

$50,000

Tiffany & Co. Schlumberger Paillonné enamel bangle

Schlumberger Bangle

Paillonné Enamel

$17,500

Donald Claflin for Tiffany & Co. enamel emerald and diamond panda brooch

Claflin Panda Brooch

Enamel & Diamond

$13,750

Past results are representative; each piece is valued on its own merits.

FORTUNA’s Tiffany & Co. Expertise

Selling a Tiffany piece at the right price takes more than an auction slot. Here’s what our specialists do for every consignment.

Authentication & Verification

Every Tiffany piece is reviewed against reference archives and, where applicable, movement/maker marks, hallmarks, and signatures — giving bidders the confidence that commands top prices.

Market Intelligence

We track the Tiffany piece market in real time — recent auction results, collector appetite, reference premiums — so your reserve and estimate are informed by current data, not stale comps.

Value Enhancement

Precise cataloging, professional photography, and targeted marketing to the right buyers are what separate a solid result from a record-setting one.

What Collectors Look For in Your Tiffany Pieces

The Tiffany secondary market rewards specific qualities. Here’s what influences the value of your pieces:

Signatures & Marks: Tiffany’s hallmarking system has evolved over nearly 200 years. Correct identification of maker’s marks, designer signatures, and date letters is essential for authentication and dating.

The Blue Box: Original Tiffany packaging (box, pouch, certificate) adds measurable value — both as authentication and as part of the collector experience. Retain all original packaging if possible.

Designer vs. Production: Named designer pieces (Schlumberger, Peretti, Picasso, Cummings) consistently outperform unsigned Tiffany production jewelry. If your piece is by a named designer, specialist cataloging matters enormously.

Condition: For enamel pieces (especially Schlumberger), condition is paramount — chips, losses, or repairs significantly affect value. Platinum and diamond pieces are more forgiving, but original finish always commands premium.

Discontinued Lines: Tiffany periodically retires popular designs. Discontinued pieces (especially Schlumberger designs no longer in production) gain scarcity value in the secondary market.

Tiffany Diamonds: Diamonds that came with Tiffany’s own grading and certification carry a brand premium. The Tiffany Setting engagement rings, Tiffany True, and Tiffany Soleste collections all have active secondary markets.

Selling Your Tiffany & Co. Is Simple

Three steps from submission to payout. No hidden fees, no surprises.

1

Submit & Reply

Fill out the valuation form with your name and email. You’ll receive an automated response right away — reply with photos and details of your Tiffany piece.

2

Preliminary Valuation

Our Tiffany piece specialists review your submission and follow up with a preliminary valuation, proposed reserve, and auction recommendation. No cost, no obligation.

3

Ship, Sell, Get Paid

Once terms are agreed, we arrange fully insured pickup, issue the final consignment agreement, and once signed our in-house team catalogs, photographs, and markets your Tiffany piece in the next appropriate auction. Net proceeds are sent shortly after the sale.

Get Your Free Tiffany & Co. Valuation

No cost, no obligation. Send us photos and details of your Tiffany piece and a specialist will follow up with a preliminary valuation.

Request Your Tiffany & Co. Valuation

It takes about two minutes. Include photos if you have them — a specialist will be in touch shortly. No cost, no obligation.

Are the items located in the United States?
PLEASE BE AWARE that we do not currently accept consignments from anywhere outside the United States.
Communication Consent
Some messages may be sent using automated technology, however, WE WILL NOT ADD YOU TO ANY AUTOMATED MARKETING LISTS. We will use your mobile number only to contact you about your valuation/consignment request. Simply reply STOP at any time to opt out. For more information, see our Privacy Policy and SMS Terms.
Communication Preference
Please let us know how you wish to be contacted. We will try to contact you via your preferred method that you select here but may use other methods if we are unsuccessful.
Do you have photos?
What type of items do you have?
Please select the category that best describes your items.
What is the approximate value of your items?
Please do your best to estimate the rough value of your item(s). If you have multiple items, estimate the total combined value.
Please describe your item(s) in the field above.
Objective
Please select (from the list above) which option most closely describes your objective?

Common Selling Questions

What’s the seller’s commission?

Our seller’s commission is presented upfront and agreed between you and FORTUNA before any item is listed — it’s locked in when we issue your consignment agreement, not discovered later. The rate is sometimes negotiable for higher-value or in-demand pieces, or for consignors bringing us large collections or full estates. Most of our fee comes from the buyer’s premium, so the seller’s commission stays modest by design.

What is a “reserve price”?

The reserve is the minimum price we will accept as a winning bid for an item. We work with a consignor on each and every item to set an appropriate reserve price, and that price is kept confidential. It is important that reserve prices not be too high, otherwise the item will never sell — and it also cannot be too low, or there is a risk the item may sell for a price that’s too low. This is where our expertise and global market experience come into play. Our experts will guide you through the process and work with you to set reserves as needed.

Do I need to send my items to you?

If you just want a rough idea of what your items are worth, we can usually give you that from photos alone. To actually consign, we need the pieces in hand — we photograph, catalog, and market every item to a global buyer pool. Your items are fully insured from the moment they leave your hands, and while in our care they’re stored in a high-security fully-insured vault.

What happens if my items don’t sell?

We can return them to you, or attempt to sell again in another auction, or perhaps try another channel altogether — such as a Buy Now listing. You’re never charged a fee for unsold lots, unlike at many other auction houses.

See all FAQs →